Overwhelmed by the sea of red lipstick options at Sephora, I decided to consult with our resident lipstick pros, Real Simple beauty editors Heather Muir and Anneke Knot. They filled me in on the red lipsticks that have garnered (many) thousands of fans over the years. Of course I couldn’t keep this insider knowledge to myself—below are nine gorgeous red lipsticks with a cult following. To buy: $34, charlottetilbury.com. To buy: $18, glossier.com. To buy: $19, nordstrom.com. To buy: $27, sephora.com. To buy: $32, neimanmarcus.com. To buy: $38, sephora.com. To buy: $10, ulta.com. To buy: $38, nordstrom.com. To buy: $22, amazon.com.
